Also, read here: The Whole Story About Subnormal Body Temperature And Ozone
| Natl Toxicol Program Tech Rep Ser 1994 Oct;440:1-314 |
OZONE LEVELS AND
THEIR EFFECTS
Data from IOA
Edited by Den (Zdenek) Rasplicka - Ozone Services
ppm = Parts per million volume air concentration
0.001 ppm
Lowest value detectable by hypersensitive humans. Too low to measure accurately
with elaborate electronic equipment.
0.003 ppm
Threshold of odor perception in laboratory environment, 50 per cent confidence
level.
0.003 ppm to
0.010 ppm
The threshold of odor perception by the average person in clean air. Readily
detectable by most normal persons. These concentrations can be measured with
fair accuracy. Ozone levels measured in typical residences and offices equipped
with a properly operating electronic air cleaner when outdoor ozone level is
low. Infiltrating outdoor ozone could cause higher indoor concentrations.
0.020 ppm
Threshold of odor perception in laboratory environment, 90 per cent confidence
level.
0.001 to 0.125
ppm
Typical ozone concentrations found in the natural atmosphere. These levels of
concentration vary with altitude, atmospheric conditions and locale.
0.020 to 0.040
ppm
Representative average total oxidant concentrations in some major cities in
1964. Approximately 95 per cent or greater of these oxidants are generally
accepted to be ozone.
0.040 ppm
CSA maximum limit for devices for household use. Measured as sustained
concentration in test room.
0.050 ppm
Maximum allowable ozone concentration recommended by ASHRAE in an air
conditioned and ventilated space.
0.050 ppm
Maximum ozone concentration produced by electronic air cleaners and similar
residential devices according to the proposed amendment of the Federal Food,
Drug and Cosmetic Act.
0.064 ppm
Proposed national ambient air quality standards for photochemical oxidants
(maximum 1 hour concentration not to be exceeded more than once per year).
0.100 ppm
The maximum allowable ozone concentration in industrial working areas:
permissible human exposure - 8 hours per day, 6 days a week.
0.100 ppm
Continuous maximum ozone concentration allowable (per U.S. Navy_ in confined
quarters such as atomic submarines.
0.100 ppm
Maximum allowable limit for industrial, public, or occupied spaces in England,
Japan, France, the Netherlands and Germany.
0.15 to 0.51 ppm
Typical peak concentrations in American cities.
0.200 ppm
Prolonged exposure of humans under occupational and experimental conditions
produced no apparent ill effects. The threshold level at which nasal and throat
irritation will result appears to be about 0.300 ppm.
0.300 ppm
The ozone level at which some species of plant life began to show signs of ozone
effects. Foliage injury appears as dark stipples, light flecks, dead patches and
general discoloration. The stomata (pores) of adult leaves are the first areas
to show signs of damage.
0.500 ppm
The ozone level at which Los Angeles, California, declares its Smog Alert No. 1.
Can cause nausea and headaches in some individuals. Extended exposure could
cause lung edema (an abnormal accumulation of serous fluid in connective tissue
or serous cavity). Enhances the susceptibility to respiratory infections.
The toxicity study above looked at ozone at the level of 1 ppm.
1.00 to 2.00 ppm
Los Angeles, California, declares its Smog Alert No. 2 at 1.00 ppm ozone
concentration and Smog Alert No. 3 at 1.500 ppm. When this range of ozone
concentration was inhaled by human volunteers for 2 hours, it caused symptoms
which could be tolerated without incapacitation with the symptoms subsiding
after a few days. The symptoms were headache, pain in the chest, and dryness of
the respiratory tract.
1.40 to 5.60 ppm
The pinto bean exposed to 1.4 to 5.0 ppm ozone concentrations for 70 minutes
showed some signs of severe injury to mature leaves.
5.00 to 25.00
ppm
Experimentation showed that a 3 hour exposure at 12 ppm was lethal for Guinea
pigs. Welders who were exposed to 9 ppm concentration plus other air pollutants
developed pulmonary edema. Chest X-rays were normal in 2 to 3 weeks, but 9
months later they still complained of fatigue and exertional dyspnea (labored
respiration).
25.00 ppm and up
Ozone concentrations that are immediately hazardous to human life are unknown
but on the basis of animal experimentation, and exposure at 50 ppm concentration
for 60 minutes would probably be fatal.
All,
NOX-OUT:
The Nox-out molecular absorber I saw advertised was a jar of pellets that
are supposed to purify the air in the room. Stuff just runs over to the jar
and jumps in, right?
ALPINE AIR PURIFIERS
The Alpine Industries air purifiers were discussed in Consumer Reports.
Included was information on the hazards of ozone, which is a toxic gas
with the same air quality standard as phosgene (chemical warfare gas). Yet
companies like Alpine Air Products and Quantum have tried so strenuously to
get you to believe that ozone is safe that it ran afoul of the courts.
According to Consumer Reports (Oct 1992, p. 661):
"Last fall, a Minnesota state court found Alpine Air Products and its
president guilty of violating consumer fraud laws for claiming that ozone is
safe and necessary indoors, has positive health benefits, poses no risk to
people with respiratory problems, and that Alpine air cleaners emit only low
and harmless levels of ozone."
Apparently, Alpine reps just don't get it. They keep saying the same
old thing. As a chemist, I am particularly appalled at the suggestion that
Carl Ross made that you should have enough ozone in the house to detoxify
your formaldehyde. Air is mostly empty space and to get a significant number
of ozone and formaldehyde molecules together to make a difference, you's have
to have very high concentrations of ozone!
This problem is addressed in an article called "Use of Ozone Generating
Devices to Improve Indoor Air Quality," Mark F. Boeniger from the National
Institute for Occupational Safety & Health, published in the American
Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, June 1995. The writer concludes that
"ozone is not a practical and effective means of improving indoor air
quality, especially in light of its potentially serious risk to health."
Anyone who wants a copy of this article can write/e-mail me their snail mail
address.
The reason these devices keep getting used is that ozone smells like "fresh
air" and can fool your nose into thinking things are better than they are.
It also deadens your ability to smell after a while.
Needless to say, Consumer Reports does not recommend any ozonizer and
neither would I. I wont even recommend ESP units if they produce
significant amounts of ozone.
To give you some perspective, I've picked out some workplace air quality
standards for some chemicals you might have heard of. The smaller the
number of parts per million (ppm), the less is allowed in the air in order to
protect workers. (Most are both ACGIH TLVs and OSHA PELs.)
AIRBORNE SUBSTANCE.....TLV &/or PEL
ethyl alcohol............1000 ppm
acetone...................750 ppm
odorless paint thinner....300 ppm
turpentine, xylene, etc...100 ppm
toluene, n-hexane..........50 ppm
ammonia, carbon monoxide...25 ppm
nitric acid.................2 ppm
formaldehyde................0.75 (OSHA standard only)
chlorine gas................0.5 ppm
ozone.......................0.1 ppm *
* And ACGIH has proposed lowering it to 0.05 ppm!
Other 0.1 ppm TLV gases include acrolein (from hot wax), bromine,
chloropicrin, dichlorvos (a pesticide now banned for household use), phosgene
(warfare gas), and stibine (antimony hydride). If you wouldn't add these to
your air, don't add ozone.
Potters have to work with enough chemicals that are potential lung hazards
without spending money on a machine that makes more.
On another subject:
LYNN'S LIST: sharp-eyed Lynn Barth sent me some glaze formulas off the
Clayart list that contain essentially no hazardous metals. They are based on
fluxes like sodium, potassium, calcium, magnesium, occasionally a little
zinc, etc. The colorants are iron primarily. These are the formulas we
should be honing to perfection for foodware.
Monona Rossol, industrial hygienist
Arts, Crafts and Theater Safety
181 Thompson St., # 23
New York, NY 10012-2586 212/777-0062
To Monona Rossol:
On Thu, 5 Sep 1996 you wrote:
>>
Yet companies like Alpine Air Products and Quantum have tried so strenuously
to get you to believe that ozone is safe that it ran afoul of the courts.
<<
Thanks for a rigorous discussion, prepared with exceptional care.
- Bill Amsterlaw
Plattsburgh, NY
Monona,
That is good advice on ozone. As a practical definition of the problems with
ozone, I would like to tell about a problem that IBM solved within the American
Airlines computer center back in the 1970s. The problem manifested itself in tw
ways: the first was an annoyance in that that certain machines would develop a
"tacky" paint after months in the computer room. If you leaned against the
machine, fibers from your clothes will stick to the paint, though none seemed to
come off on your clothes. The second problem was more serious, causing
computer down-time. Rubber shock cushions under rotating disk units were
disintegrating within 6 to 9 months. Also transfer valves in the vaccum collums
tape drives were failing at a rate that was 2 to 3 time higher than in similar
installations.
The cause of the problem was finally traced to the fact that American Airlines w
using an electrostatic precipitator to "clean" the air in the computer room of d
While the electrostatic charge was knocking the dust from the air, it was also
building up the quantity of ozone, causing any rubberized parts to disintegrate.
Yes, the paint on the "tacky" machines was a latex base. The same ozone
problem causes rubber windshield wipers to fail quickly in Los Angeles basin.
Thank goodness they don't get much rain.
wrolley@garlic.com CrossPlatform Creativity
Reflections Publishing, Inc. CrossPlatform Multimedia Development
I have to comment on that,
for the alpine air purifier to produce an even harmful amount of ozone, it
would take one of the models made for 2500 Square feet in a 10x10 room full
blast. it produces such a minute amount that it has passed all the lab tests.
The Alpine Air purifiers produce only enough for it to be beneficial when
used correctly. It says clearly right on the machine the square footage for
it to cover at a safe level. It really is less than .04 parts per million
which is within the guideline for it being beneficial.
The ozone makes it merely like it was just after a thunderstorm all the time.
Gotta go,
Carl in Phillips
At 08:00 AM 9/7/96 EDT, you (Carl Ross) wrote: *** in part ***
>----------------------------Original message----------------------------
>I have to comment on that,
>
It really is less than .04 parts per million
>which is within the guideline for it being beneficial.
>Carl in Phillips
>
Carl- Just what guidlines are those ? please give me a reference I can check.
Bill- being very skeptical on Persimmon Hill
Bill Aycock --- Persimmon Hill --- Woodville, Alabama, USA --- (in
the N.E. corner of the State)
also-- W4BSG -- Grid EM64
Bill,
I must be honest in saying that this is the only time anyone ever questioned
this before. The people who first made the Apline Air Purifiers did plenty of
research as to whether it is safe or not. The only reason they are not UL
listed is that they are the first of their kind. They are often imitated but
never paralleled. The Underwriters Laboratories is still looking at these
machines and are stumped, because they have nothing to compare them to. If
you give me your Address I'll send you a focus pack which will tell you all
the scientific stuff you need to know. All I know is they work and the only
problem I have had is when we first plugged it in we had to keep it a little
low because it had to have time to clean the air first. If you want we sold
one to a friend in Texas. Her E-mail address is ktjude@intertex.net. my
father met her through a list and she turned me on to Vince's Colored Clay
workshop, and Clayart.
I hope this reassures you.
Gotta Go,
Carl in Phillips
P.S. I would be glad to have a conference call with some of the people that
know more about it than me. I just try to watch so people can be aware of all
their options.
Check out this sight also
http://members.aol.com/Yumeni/essen.htm
I just looked under ozone.
You may want to look around some of the other sites also.
At 11:07 PM 9/8/96 EDT, you wrote: *** in part ***
>----------------------------Original message----------------------------
>Bill,
>
>I must be honest in saying that this is the only time anyone ever questioned
>this before.
>Carl in Phillips
>
Carl- I think you misunderstood my question. I have no need for information
re the Alpine machine,( at least at this time) and only asked for data to
quantify the "beneficial level" of Ozone.
I know what Ozone is, and how it smells, and some ways it is generated.
What I dont have a clue about is any level that is good, and what research
substantiates it. I looked at the reference you mentioned (will read it
carefully later), and the first two pages had only vague
generalities. I dont need any brochures, just information.
Thanks- Bill- living in relatively clean air, on Persimmon Hill.
>
Bill Aycock --- Persimmon Hill --- Woodville, Alabama, USA --- (in
the N.E. corner of the State)
also-- W4BSG -- Grid EM64
I must add that I just heard from our up line that Alpine Air purifiers will
soon have a sensor that will act as an ozone thermostat. it will also soon
have a light indicating ionization.
sorry to clog up the list with irrelavent info.
Carl
| Alpine Faces Contempt Charge | ||
WASHINGTON, April 18, 2000 -- The Federal Trade Commission and the Department of Justice have filed a motion in Federal Court to hold Alpine Industries, its officers and a related company, EcoQuest International in civil contempt of a Court order issued in January 2000.
The government is asking the Court to order the companies to stop making prohibited claims in marketing their air cleaning products, remove prohibited product claims from their Web sites, and impose daily fines if they continue to violate the order.
In January, a Federal judge ordered Alpine, a manufacturer of ozone generating air treatment machines, to stop claiming that its machines provide relief from any medical condition or that they effectively remove or reduce a wide variety of air pollutants from indoor environments. The injunction followed a November 1, 1999, verdict in which a Federal jury found unanimously that Alpine violated a 1995 FTC order by failing to have "competent and reliable scientific evidence" to support hundreds of claims for their air cleaning products. Alpine was also found to make unsupported claims that its products control indoor ozone levels.
The government's motion alleges that Alpine violated the January order by making prohibited claims about its ozone generators. Shortly after the Court's January order, Alpine sold its marketing operations to EcoQuest International, a new corporation.
Alpine Industries is a privately held, multi-level marketing company that claims to have between 75,000 and 100,000 active dealers nationwide. Its main facilities are in Greene County, Tennessee. William J. Converse is the company's president and chief executive officer. Michael Jackson is vice president and heads the company's marketing activities, which are now run by him through EcoQuest. The flagship product of Alpine Industries is the XL-15, which sells for approximately $600 per unit.

EcoQuest Intl
Here is a News Article about Alpine and Ecoquest Intl
Alpine Industries ‘Spins Off’ New Firm, EcoQuest International
By: By CAMERON JUDD/Assistant Managing Editor
Source: The Greeneville Sun 01-17-2000
Alpine Industries Inc., the Greeneville-based major manufacturer of indoor
air and water purification appliances, is spinning off its marketing and
distribution services to create a new company.
Bill Converse, president and founder of Alpine, told approximately 550 mployees
at the company’s Mt. Pleasant Industrial Park headquarters and manufacturing
facility this morning that a company called EcoQuest International has been
formed to take over the multi-level marketing network through which Alpine’s
products are sold.
EcoQuest International will be solely owned by Michael Jackson, who has been
a co-owner and executive vice president of Alpine, according to a spokesperson.
Jackson has been Converse’s partner in Alpine since 1994.
EcoQuest will assume ownership of Alpine’s entire dealer network, which includes
more than 150,000 active dealers nationwide, Alpine announced in a press release
issued this morning.
At the same time, Eva Converse, Bill Converse’s wife, will become the sole owner
of Alpine Industries, while Bill Converse will continue as president.
Previously, Jackson was an Alpine co-owner.
Terms of the business reorganization, indicating who paid what to whom, were not
disclosed. A spokesperson said that the business reorganization is “in process”
and is expected to be completed by the end of this month.
EcoQuest also will assume ownership of related computer hardware and software
and the trade names for Living Air, Living Water, Alive and Wellness and other
current Alpine products.
The press release stated, “EcoQuest will continue to focus on providing
consumers with innovative products and services designed to enhance the quality,
safety, convenience and comfort of indoor living — which is at the core of
Alpine’s technologies — expanding its product line to include items produced by
other manufacturers as well.”
Converse’s Role BR> Converse said he will head Alpine’s science and
engineering functions, with Alpine becoming what the press release calls “a
focused research and development-based manufacturer of environmental
technologies and appliances.”
For the time being, both companies will continue to operate out of the same Mt.
Pleasant Industrial Park facility, according to Cindy McConkey, who handles
Alpine’s and EcoQuest’s public relations and information functions through the
Knoxville-based Ackermann Public Relations and Marketing firm.
In a telephone interview this morning, McConkey said that both Alpine and
EcoQuest expect to grow through the years, a statement indicating that a
division into new, separate facilities could happen later, along with new jobs.
Although no official timetable for such further developments is in place, “this
is a growth plan,” McConkey said, referring to the restructuring.
Advance Notice Given
Advance word of today’s announcement was given over the weekend to about 350 of
Alpine’s top dealers, who had gathered in San Antonio, Texas, for the company’s
annual “bonus banquet,” at which awards, bonuses, etc., are given to top-performingdistributors.
The announcement, made in Texas by Converse, was “well-received” by the dealers,
McConkey said.
Under the restructuring, Alpine will continue to develop and produce
products, and EcoQuest will be given the opportunity to obtain first rights to
market them.
Such rights have already been obtained by EcoQuest for Alpine’s best-known
existing product lines, she said.
Should EcoQuest decline to pick up marketing rights for future products, Alpine
will have the right to distribute them in other ways, McConkey said.
Headquarters To Stay Here
Converse was quoted in the press release as saying, “‘If you had told me that
what I started in the basement of my home 14 years ago would become a $200
million company with more than 700 employees locally and across the country and
an international distribution network of more than 350,000 distributors, I would
have wondered what you had been inhaling.’”
Converse continued, in the press release: “‘Alpine Industries has been so
successful, and I’m so proud of our engineering team, of the people here at this
plant who make our products, of my partner and friend, Michael Jackson, and of
all of our distributors who understand the need for our products and the
business opportunity we’ve created for them. This is a great platform for going
on to the next level.’”
Converse emphasized in the release that both Alpine Industries’ science and
engineering and the new company, EcoQuest, would remain headquartered in
Greeneville, which he said “has proven to be an ideal place to do business.”
‘Not Related To FTC Case
McConkey told the Sun this morning that she has heard informal discussions of
the idea for many months.
Alpine leaders made a conscious decision, she said, to go ahead with an idea
that was needed for the welfare and growth of its business, despite the
inevitability that speculation would be made attempting to link the move to the
FTC matter.
In November 1999, Alpine Industries and Converse lost on most points of a civil
lawsuit brought against them on behalf of the United States, through the FTC,
alleging that the company lacked “competent and reliable scientific evidence” to
back many of its claims regarding the efficacy of its air cleaning products.
Attorneys for Alpine and Converse have said they plan to seek either a new trial
or a new verdict in the case.
The restructuring “‘is a significant change in our business strategy, and
that’s not something you conjure up overnight,’" Converse stated in the press
release.
“‘This has nothing to do with the FTC case. Alpine Industries will continue to
act in good faith to meet all of its responsibilities.
“‘The restructuring is something we have been working toward for some time now
as part of our long-range growth strategy. As a courtesy, we already have
discussed it with the judge overseeing the case and notified the FTC of our
plans.”
No response had been received from the FTC about the announcement as of this
morning, McConkey said.
‘Level Requires More Focus’
The press release continues to quote Converse: “‘We simply are at the maturity
level in this company that requires us to become even more focused — and what
Michael (Jackson) does best is the marketing and distribution, while my true
strengths lie in research and development.
“‘In the last year or so, we had found ourselves limited in many ways. And when
that happens, you have to find ways to get beyond the plateau and begin climbing
new summits.’”
According to the press release, Alpine Industries has grown from a base of
revenues of $7 million in 1994 to $187 million in 1997.
During that same time period, its dealer base ballooned from 20,000 to nearly
250,000, a figure now up to 350,000, McConkey said. About 150,000 of those
dealers are actively selling the products.
In 1998, the company was recognized for its business success, ranking 84th on
the prestigious Inc. 500 list of the fastest growing companies in America.
Alpine Industries has been honored as the Multi-Level Marketing Company of the
Year three times in recent years by various trade organizations and trade media.
Converse is further quoted in the release: “‘We
have been in the midst of developing some exciting new products and new
technologies through our engineering and R-and-D (research and development)
function, only to have to set that work aside because it did not fit into the
abilities of our sales network.
“‘Sales and marketing of highly technical equipment, often developed for
specific, science-based niches, require a very different approach to sales than
the diverse, consumer-focused sales network we have in place today.
“‘Alpine Industries’ science and engineering has the ability to develop cutting
edge technologies with large-scale applications for food processing, water
quality, waste management and farming.
“‘By restructuring and tightening our focus on engineering, development and
manufacturing, we are free to work with other technology companies and
laboratories to pursue these business opportunities nationally and
internationally.’”
Converse said that Alpine will have to build a small, more traditional sales and
marketing function internally, the release stated.
But he also noted that the restructuring “does not mean a parting of ways
between Alpine and the dealer network that we started, or Michael Jackson and
me, for that matter, although we will be two separate companies.”
He added in the release that other contractual agreements “will provide a
win-win relationship” between the two companies as they move forward.
“For instance,” the release stated, “provisions have been made to provide
incentives to the EcoQuest sales network to allow its dealers to benefit from
bringing a new product opportunity to Alpine.”
Michael Jackson Quoted
Jackson is also quoted in the release: “‘EcoQuest International will expand and
grow at an even faster pace due to this business development. We will expand our
product line to include new products to enhance and advance the quality of
living indoors.
“‘We have more than 3 million Living Air sales, stacks of testimonial letters
from satisfied customers and 14 years of successful home-based business building
backing us up.
“‘That’s an incredible foundation to build on. Now, with this spin-off of the
new company, we fully expect to see this business explode.’”
The release adds: “In addition to the sales force, EcoQuest also will acquire
the customer service, marketing and creative services functions needed to
support the multi-level marketing business, Jackson said.
“Long-range plans include exploring shared ownership to EcoQuest field leaders
and key employees and a possible initial public offering within the next 48
months.”
— Managing Editor Douglas Watson also contributed to this article.
To find out more about EcoQuest Intl and their Products go to EcoQuest or email Bill Goddard with your Questions.
|
I promise to answer your message -- click here to send me a personal message
|
SUBSCRIBE: The Wednesday Letter is a free electronic monthly newsletter written and published by Karl Loren. You can view more than 50 back issues of this publication by clicking here. The Wednesday Letter subscription list is maintained on a secure server, no name is ever given or sold to anyone, and it is never used except for this Newsletter. It is automatically published on the Tuesday night just before the first Wednesday of every month. You can subscribe to this free monthly electronic letter by entering your eMail address and name below. You will then automatically receive a request for confirmation, sent to whatever address you have entered. If you do NOT receive this confirmation request, then you will not be subscribed. There may have been an error with your address and you should resubmit. The letter is never sent twice to the same address -- so you do not have to worry about a duplicate subscription. When you receive this confirmation request you must reply to it, or your subscription will not become active. No one can subscribe your name, and address, without you being notified, and if you get an unwanted notice of subscription you only need to DO NOTHING and the subscription will NOT be active.
REMOVAL: You can remove yourself from the subscription list in several different ways. Click here to read about this entire newsletter system. Every edition of The Wednesday Letter is delivered to your address with YOUR name and address in view on the letter, with a link that allows you to remove THAT name from the subscription list. If you try to send this removal message from an address different from the one you used to send in your original confirmation, then you will get a warning notice first, sent to the subscription address, asking you to confirm that you want to be removed from the list -- by replying to THAT request for confirmation, you will then be automatically removed. Thus, no one else can unsubscribe you, from some other computer, without your knowledge. But, if you send in the unsubscribe notice from the same machine used to receive the Letter, then the removal from the subscription list is automatic.
Personal Message: When you send a personal message to Karl Loren, you will receive a personal reply as per his instructions. Karl pledges that every personal message will get a personal answer. When you provide your mail address, we will send you free information including our free catalog and a cassette tape lecture by Karl Loren about heart disease, no charge, by mail, even if outside the US. You can select particular information you would like to receive, along with the free cassette tape and catalog.
You can reach Vibrant Life in many ways, including by mail to Vibrant Life, 2808 N. Naomi St., Burbank, CA 91504. Within the US and Canada, use the toll free number: (800) 523-4521, the local number: (818) 558-1799, the FAX: (818) 558-7299, eMail to kimberly@oralchelation.com or any one of the hundreds of message forms throughout the 50 web sites. Vibrant Life normally ships the same day we get an order. There are message forms on each of the 100,000+ pages on this and other sites where you can communicate with Vibrant Life. Check out our companion site, at: http://www.oralchelation.net where Karl's 2000 page book is published. Karl Loren is the author and webmaster for this BOOK, as well as for another web site about ORAL CHELATION. His personal philosophical articles are at PHILOSOPHY.
Copyright © May 20, 2008 6:23 AM by Karl Loren on behalf of Vibrant Life, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Permission is granted for non-commercial downloading, copying, distribution or redistribution on two conditions: One, that some form of copyright notice is included in every copy distributed or copied, showing the copyright belonging to Vibrant Life, Burbank, CA, at www.oralchelation.com . The second condition is that the material is not to be used for any purpose contrary to the purposes and objectives of this site. This permission does not extend to materials on this site which are copyrighted by others.